Takaki lays out the context for each situation, subverts the narrative of passive victimhood, and zeroes in on the perseverance and agency of each group. I am glad that I read it. Takaki is an excellent writer and a thorough researcher. But if you liked Howard Zinn's 'A People's History Of The United States' you might like this. Takaki is an excellent writer and a thorough researcher.
It deals with, in roughly sequential order, , pre- and post-slavery era, , Mexicans, , , , , and ties up the book with a current for the time the book was written summary of where minorities are now. Williams Library, University of Mississippi. This was not the America I learned abou This book is only 400 pages, but it took me three-and-a-half months to read it. It's factual, it's informative, it's not poorly written, it's just dreadfully boring. However, I really thought it so worthwhile. Essential Listening Every cultural group has a story, but those stories aren't isolated. The dates within each chapter were a bit jumbled up, but everything still made sense.
Some chapters of this book were assigned reading for my American history course, so I had expected a struggle. . One of the most important periods of time for this country was during the period of conflict between Americans and Native Americans over land rights. It gets annoying after the third time. Often times I think our American history is Anglo biased, leaving out the rest of us feeling marginalized or not significant enough to warrant more than a paragraph or a chapter at best. In Double Victory, Takaki introduces different revisionist arguments that I will be discussing… 1270 Words 5 Pages Race can be categorized quite differently and can vary from country to country. This book gives an outline of how America has become the multicultural world it is today.
It left me knowing that the story I'd been taught many years earlier was a prideful re-writing of a much more checkered past. Otherwise, the very groups you aim to humanize back into the story are exploited as props and placeholders in your own version of history, and stripped of their humanity all the same. First, he never seems to go for big effects - no action scenes, no hard contrasts to evoke a reaction. If you ever wonder why a group of people are in this land, this is the book to reveal that and much more. I just now learned that Chinese and Japanese immigrants were not allowed to become naturalized citizens until 1943? This is a powerful and moving work that will resonate for all Americans, who together make up a nation of immigrants from other shores. The book is an excellent companion to. It's the story of America outside of government decisions; America as it's lived by the peoples affected by those decisions.
This book provides the reader with the American experience of Native Americans, African Americans, Mexican Americans, Irish Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, and Jewish Americans. That said, this collection was well executed and is definitely worth a read. An interesting read for one who only learned history written by the race in dominance. As you'd expect from the above, so many of these stories are sad. We don't really hear their stories though. While it is structured chronologically, it is broken into racial groups ex: 1880s from the perspectives of Mexican Americans, Chinese immigrants, Irish immigrants, and African Americans.
Yes, we do need to acknowledge the role of privilege throughout American history, privilege of race, sex, religion, association, and so on. As one of only two on campus, he gained a new awareness of his ethnic identity. The narrative is laced with short quotations, cameos of personal experiences, and excerpts from folk music and literature. So much energy dedicated to the suppression of the Other. The most important contribution this book has, though, is the thorough in-depth narratives from Native Americans, especially before 1776, and the elucidation of how colonists systematically disenfranchised Native American people and African Americans as well.
I believe that these writers and historians are acting in good faith and aim to right the wrongs of history. The accounts of ethnic minority groups in the U. Our president-elect and all the extremists of his party are see 4. Paulo Freire's work has helped to empower countless people throughout the world and has taken on special urgency in the United States and Western Europe, where the creation of a permanent underclass among the underprivileged and minorities in cities and urban centers is ongoing. This book should be required reading in U. I strongly, strongly recommend this! A book I did not know I needed.
Now, Ronald Takaki has revised his landmark work and made it even more relevant and important. And second, I don't want to over-sell this book, but I really thought it was an excellent work of history and of writing, and there's no way I could capture that in a review. It took me a while to read because there is so much to digest. This was definitely a different take on the American history I had in K12. He is the author of six books, including Strangers from a Different Shore. I want to be careful with this point so that it's clear what I'm saying, and what I'm not saying.